Skypegear guide: Which Skype phone to buy for which family member?
By
Stephen Pinches on November 9, 2006 in Christmas gifts.
As I wrote earlier, amazon.co.uk has predicted that Skype phones will be a top present this Christmas. Great - but as any hardened Christmas gift-buyer knows, the real art is matching the exactly right one to the right family member.
No two families are the same, but it's definitely true that what Young Kevin might want will be completely different than his Gran or mad Uncle Frankie. So with the aim of Peace to all Men (and Women...) here's my attempt to point you in at least (I hope!) the right general direction...
Gramophone Granny and Grandad. They may not be spending hours updating their MySpace profiles, but Gran and Grandad have got email sorted and want to keep in touch with the rest of the family more than ever, especially now their grand-daughter's backpacking round Australia. You've shown them Skype, but they're still a bit wary.
My advice: Providing they already have a broadband router, the Philips VOIP841 should be available before Christmas, and this should do the trick nicely. It plugs straight into the router and the landline socket, meaning the PC doesn't even have to be on to use it. It might also be worth thinking about an easy-to-use webcam such as the Logitech QuickCam Communicate STX, so you can keep in touch over video calls. It's also worth considering a simple device such as the VoSky phone wizard, which will let them make Skype calls straight from their normal telephone, so long as the computer's powered up. These cost £39.45 / €58,45 / $44.95.
Gadget Dad. He's got an iPod full of Coldplay, and a plasma TV the size of Belgium. There's nothing *wrong* with the cordless phone he bought two years ago, but those Skype phones they've been talking about down the golf club could be just the job...
My advice: The Belkin wifi phone is neat, shiny and black. It can be used out of the house with any Wifi network that doesn't require web-based signup, as well as on your home network. It doesn't require a PC to work, and is available for preorder in the US for $189.99, or to buy in the UK from morecomputers.co.uk for the frankly bargain price of £91.
Multitasking Mum. She's running a successful design business from the back room, taking the kids to school and keeping up with a packed social calendar. She needs something which will look the part on her desk, and give crystal clear calls so she doesn't miss a trick when she's talking to clients.
My advice: The Logitech Easycall Desktop provides everything you need if you're working from home: a really great wireless keyboard and mouse, and a Skype-certified speakerphone plus headphones. The keyboard has all the controls you need to power both Skype and your music, and will automatically mute music to take a call. The Logitech will set you back a reasonable £90 / €129,95.
Teenager Kevin. He hardly says a word, so it's a mystery how he manages to run up such big bills on the phone! He's a 'digital native', spends hours on MySpace, and has enough Skype contacts to fill an Ibiza nightclub. Using a landline phone is just so lame.
My advice: The Netgear SPH101Wifi phone is probably the most advanced Skype phone at the moment. As it's wifi calls can be made from the privacy of a triple-locked bedroom, and it should withstand being thrown around next year when the boys are round playing some Nintendo...
Little Maggie. Frankly, when it comes to presents the packaging is normally the most interesting part for her. But Dad's away a lot and it'd be great if she could hear his voice every now and again...
My advice: A Verball is the gift that just keeps on giving. It's a cool cuddly speakerphone, so when Dad or Mum are away they can speak to their little darlings (or each other) on Skype via the medium of a cuddly toy. Weird at first? You betcha. Give it a try though - they'll even sing your MP3s for you!
Mad uncle Frankie. Flown in from New Zealand, you only see him once a year, and he tends to have emptied the cocktail cabinet before breakfast. Still, family are family, so it'd be great if you could use Skype to talk to him so you can save up to replace that bottle of 10 year old Single Malt.
My advice: The USRobotics USB Internet Mini Phone phone is a good, simple Skype phone. At £13 / €20 / $25 it won't break the bank, but will allow you to easily keep in touch. It's small enough to be easily portable, and the design is easy enough to use for anyone familiar with a mobile phone. Check out more simple plug-in Skype phones here.
For reviews of these and many more Skype phones, check out Voip-Sol.com, Skypejournal, Gizmodo, and Engadget. Oh, and Happy Holidays.






Comments
Cute little general review, but leaves me still wondering what might be MY least-cost best choice. I have a hearing problem, but find my hearing aid incompatible with ordinary telephones -- so must guess as to much of the conversation and sometimes can't hear the other party at all. So, I need a unit that could substitute for a regular telephone or be used interchangably with Skype; it should have a mini-jack to accommodate an earpiece when necessary; and (for frosting on the cake) would do well to be Bluetooth-enabled so as to send and receive ordinary local and long-distance phone calls over the Bluetooth radio built into my Prius (as I do currently with my Motorola RAZR cell phone). Can someone narrow down the options? Also, given that I must pay a phone carrier to supply my DSL internet, can the cost of that connection be minimized by means of any of the Skype phones?
vantage601 | Tuesday, Nov 14
Thanks for the comment. On hearing-aid compatibility and the best phones for the hard of hearing, I want to do a specific post on this very soon. Word has it that the GE-branded 28300EE2 for example is hearing aid compatible and I am trying to verify that. In terms of minimising cost of DSL via Skype - there's no specific way to lower the cost of the actual DSL, but the new SMC wifi phone package I posted on yesterday is quite a good deal and includes a wifi router (but no modem). On the Bluetooth radio in the Prius (I had no idea Priuses had such cool radios!), you could look at getting a Pocket PC-powered mobile phone such as the Cingular 8525 (has different names depending on the carrier) combined with the Skype for Pocket PC software. This way as far as I can see you should be able to make Skype calls via your data connection on the phone and route them through the Bluetooth radio. However, this will be dependent on the speed of the data connection (try to get a 3G-compatible phone), and the level of Bluetooth support that your Bluetooth stereo allows. Also, I would make sure you're on a flat-rate data plan with the mobile company if you're going down this route. Hope that helps...
slaymakerpinches | Wednesday, Nov 15